Wednesday, January 21, 2009

Slumdog Millionaire: India Shining?


"The British colonialists once ruled; now look, they are laughing at us and winning awards too," is the thrust of some English language press reviews of this overhyped movie. I pity the Indian electronic media and critics who are showing child-like enthusiasm over the success of the movie. The overcrowded cinemas are nothing but a cruel reminder of the very fact of the infamous term about today's India: India shining. The cosmetic effect of the Bollywood style of a slum dweller gaining riches has blinded the Indian public and critics to the real depiction and portrayal of Mumbai's slums. They have failed to look at the shitholes in which the slum dwellers prefer to jump into for a glimpse of Amitabh Bachan (who coincidently has critically discussed the movie on his blog and shown his disgust over the same issues). There cannot be a bigger irony than the sight of a private helicopter and the shit smeared kid dying to get an autograph of Mr. Bachan. India seems to be more interested in the correct answer that would win Jamal a few thousand rupees than the Hindu's massacre of Muslims that taught him the right answer. India is more interested in the utopian Bollywood theme of the hero finding the girl of his dreams at the end of the movie than pondering upon the life story of Latika that passes through a begging camp, a brothel, a rape and the bedroom of a gangster. The most ironic part of the movie is the theme of the movie itself: a popular international show ‘who wants to be a millionaire’.
I fail to find a genuine reason of the hype created by the movie and even disappointed by the awards bestowed upon it by the Golden Globe. It is just another ‘masala’ movie with endless flaws of facts. However, there is one point to be learnt from the movie and that is the pathetic state of the society of the largest democracy of the world and of a nation that is aspiring to be recognized as a regional super power. The fact remains that India has a society which is shallow, intolerant, racist and greedy. India’s cosmetic feel-good image is confined to Bollywood and its media which in fact shall prove to be counter-productive because closing eyes to the problems and portraying these problems as glamour justifies these terrible issues as acceptable in the deteriorating society of India. The term ‘India shining’ reminds me of a proverb that I learnt in school when I was a kid. All that glitters is not gold. I am positive that the shine of India that I see on media is definitely not that of Gold.

6 comments:

Syed Bilal Bukhari said...

I cant believe you wrote this. Whatever you portrayed as design flaws in the movie, is in fact the very reason the movie is doing so well. The people, in my opinion, who seem to like it understand the irony in a superstar's helicopter and a child covered in shit wanting his autograph. They do, we all do. The essence of the movie is far more profound than a narrative of an average Joe making it big. Not at all! Rather, it portrays a candid picture of what actually is happening in the real India, not the one that's shinning and flexing its muscles for regional domination. Why should film-makers feel ashamed for such efforts? I fail to understand.

Faysal Bukhari said...

Exactly my point. I havent discussed the movie per se. I have discussed and hilighted the 'irony' of Indian society. Infact, I have used the word 'irony' and 'ironic' more than once.

Syed Bilal Bukhari said...

But you did discuss the movie in its literal sense, didn't you? Well at least thats the impression I got from your article. Anyhow AR Rehman is up for three Oscars! and the movie is up for ten in total!

I have yet to learn about Oscars.

Fahd Mirza said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Ghazala Khan said...

Interview Request:

Hello Dear and Respected,
I hope you are fine and carrying on the great work you have been doing for the Pakistani side of Internet. I am Ghazala Khan from The Pakistani Spectator (TPS), We at TPS throw a candid look on everything happening in and for Pakistan. We are trying to contribute our humble share in the blogistan.

We at TPS are carrying out a new series of interviews with the notable Pakistani bloggers, writers and web masters. In that regard, We would like to interview you, if you please take some time out of your busy schedule. Please send me your approval for your interview at ghazala.khi at gmail.com, so that I could send you the questions. We would be extremely grateful. We have done many interviews with many bloggers from Pakistan like Dr. Awab, Kashif Aziz, Fahd Mirza, Unaiza Nasim, Omer Alvi and host of others. We have also interviewed prominent figures like renowned writer Dr. Ayesha Siddiqa Agha, Dawn Columnist Urdsher Cowasjee and plethora of others.

regards.

Ghazala Khan
The Pakistani Spectator
http://www.pakspectator.com

Salamat Tabahi said...
This comment has been removed by the author.